Almost from the outset of television drama, the subject of warfare has been one of the prime staples of the medium. From the early days of the simple 'Gung Ho' exploits of starkly overly idealised stories of the adventures of fearless fighting men through to today's more realistically shaded, measured and morally complex depictions of the true, often horrific nature of combat, arguably the most recent dramatic pinnacle of contemporary television's on-going fascination with the subject of men at war was Band of Brothers.
The genesis of the television adaptation of historian
Stephen E. Ambrose's epic best selling book arose following the completion of
the critically acclaimed motion picture Saving Private Ryan, when director
Steven Spielberg and star Tom Hanks were both individually contemplating
developing projects based upon two of Ambrose's books. When the two giants of
the industry finally decided that rather than pursue separate projects they
would instead collaborate, Spielberg set aside his plans for the adaptation of
"Citizen Soldiers", in favour of Hanks' preference, "Band of
Both book and mini series chronicle the experiences of the
men of Easy Company, a unit of 147 combat paratroopers from their first day of
training onwards via the major landmark events of the brutal conflicts of the
European Theatre of War including D-Day, Holland, Market-Garden, the Battle of
the Bulge, and the capture of Hitler's Eagle's Nest through to the end of the
Having enjoyed an earlier Emmy award-winning collaborative
success for the mini series, From the Earth to the Moon, Hanks was keen to
realise the project with cable channel HBO for reasons he commented on at the
time: "I have a great history with HBO, we've done this kind of thing
before. They understand the type of authenticity we're going for and they throw
away all the rules - we can say what we want to, the stories can last as long
as they need to, and we, as storytellers, think that's very important."
With the arrival of Tony To, whom had been a key member of
Hanks' production team on From the Earth to the Moon; casting for Band of
Brothers got underway. Concerned more with finding actors who could convey the
emotional essence of the characters rather than concentrating on their physical
likenesses, the list of hopefuls was eventually narrowed down to the final 50
actors who would embody the television incarnations of Ambrose's Easy Company,
with Spielberg himself operating the camera and Hanks staging the action for
the sessions and keeping a watchful eye on how the actors interacted with each
other in differing roles to finally match the right part for each man..
However, for the crucial roles of Richard Winters, who was to become Easy
Company's commanding officer, and Winter's closest friend, Lewis Nixon, rising
young English actor Damian Lewis and American Ron Livingston were cast almost
upon first walking through the door of the casting session.
Having previously met with the real Winters, Hanks had clear
ideas of the qualities needed to secure the role: "an enigmatic leader
who, at the same time, is the exact symbol that you would want to have for a
leader; a guy you can't explain, but who explains himself by his mere presence.
And in that case, you're looking for something chromosomal. You're looking for
someone with a certain air about them that comes across even before he opens
his mouth, and Damian had that without question. As soon as he sat down, we
Prior to filming, the newly formed group of actors undertook a tough, gruelling and uncompromising two-week boot camp overseen by Captain Dale Dye, USMC (ret.), the hard-bitten, no-nonsense former soldier given the task of transforming a loose group of men into a fully functioning, highly trained company of soldiers. Having reaped the benefits of employing a similar approach with "Saving Private Ryan," Hanks and Spielberg were convinced that such a course of intensive training was an essential, process, as well as providing perhaps the most important and effective rehearsal time possible for the actors. In essence, the training at Captain Dye's boot camp successfully transformed a group of actors into effective soldiers and the spirit of Easy Company became a reality.
The actors cast and successfully moulded them into a tight
and effective unit, the production team next turned its attention to deciding
on and securing the perfect location to realise the 11 towns, fields and
forests necessary for Easy Company's odyssey across the blood-soaked ground of
the European Theatre of War. To this end, Spielberg and Hanks opted to return
to the Hatfield Aerodrome outside of London, a location that offered office
space, empty aeroplane hangars for sets, and 1000 acres of open space, where
sections of "Saving Private Ryan" had previously been filmed. As
Hanks observed about their choice of location: "it's a first-rate
production facility for recreating the past, as well as creating the next
generation of special effects."
Despite the production being allocated a different direction
for each episode, the producers took great care in ensuring that an overall
coherence and style was adhered to which ultimately lent the finished
production its final, memorably gritty, almost documentary-like visual style.
As Tony To explained: "Steven [Spielberg] has set such a template for us
with "Ryan" that we agreed to use the filmmaking languages he created
there - the handheld, subjective point of view, the image shaker, the grunt's
view of the battle. From that basic template, we've let the directors evolve it
into something new, something that will become identifiable as 'Band of
But ultimately, what makes Band of Brothers the powerful,
emotive and memorable example of superior big-budget television drama that it
undoubtedly is, is the core honesty, integrity and total conviction brought to
the screen by the simply superb performances from an unusually large, but
unquestionably perfectly cast and committed ensemble group of actors. Through
their sensitive, unsentimental interpretation of the intelligently adapted
scripts, we the viewers are presented with a compelling yet insightful and
intimate portrait of the ravaging, dehumanising effects of war on ordinary men
faced with having to deal with the reality of senselessly violent, sometimes
seemingly insane, extraordinary situations. Perhaps more than any other theme
which it deals with, Band of Brothers successfully and powerfully illustrates
the loss of innocence experienced by the entire civilised world due to the
effects of war by concentrating on the smaller, more intimate loss of innocence
and heavy sacrifice experienced by the small, yet diverse group of men who made
up the ranks of Easy Company.
Perhaps it’s only fitting for the final - accurate -
summation of the success of Band of Brothers should come directly from Tom
Hanks himself: "the hope that the viewer will have an emotional and human
experience that will allow them to appreciate the sacrifice that the men who
fought in the Second World War gave."
Published on November 28th, 2018. Review: Steve Hulse (2005).