Broken Horseshoe

The Broken Horseshoe

1952 - United Kingdom

Francis Durbridge was best known as the creator of Paul Temple. When it was announced that he was working on his first television serial, many fans assumed that Temple would feature in the series. Durbridge received a large number of letters expressing excitement about seeing Temple on television and wishing him success with the character’s TV debut. However, as he explained in the Radio Times in March 1952, the central character in The Broken Horseshoe, Mark Fenton, was quite different from Paul Temple.

“To start with, he is neither a novelist nor a private detective,” Durbridge noted. “He doesn’t even read detective stories!”

Durbridge admitted that he had been fascinated by television drama since the early pre-war broadcasts from Alexandra Palace. He had also spent a month in the United States, "popping in and out of studios, watching rehearsals, and discussing the problems which face all writers and producers when—with trepidation—they turn towards the magic of television."

The Broken Horseshoe was a 30-minute British television serial broadcast over six consecutive Saturday nights. It holds the distinction of being the BBC’s first televised thriller serial. The series starred John Robinson (later known for playing Professor Bernard Quatermass in Quatermass II). The mystery begins when a man named Charles Constance is struck by a car and taken to a London hospital. He is operated on by a conscientious doctor, Mark Fenton (Robinson). However, it is soon revealed that the patient was involved with a horse-doping gang and is later murdered by the syndicate. The doctor, by unfortunate circumstance, becomes the prime suspect.

The only person who can clear his name is a young woman—played by Barbara Lott (Sorry! and 2point4 Children)—who witnessed the murder. The cast also included Russell Hunter (Callan), Noel Howlett (Please Sir!), and Delphi Lawrence. As was typical of the time, the episodes were broadcast live, and no telerecording was made. A 77-minute film adaptation was released in 1953 as a British B-movie, starring Robert Beatty and Elizabeth Sellers.

Durbridge once recounted an amusing incident from his trip to America. Upon arrival, he was stopped by a New York customs officer.

“He went through my cases with a fine-tooth comb and eventually pulled out a copy of one of my radio thrillers. He turned it over, examined it from cover to cover, looked at the binding, flicked through the pages—presumably in search of hidden diamonds. Eventually, he looked up and asked, out of the side of his mouth: ‘What’s d’is?’

I told him it was the script of a play.

‘A moider play?’

I said yes, it was a murder play.

He shook his head and raised his hands in a gesture of despair. ‘Every week I listen to d’ese things on the radio,’ he said. ‘An’ every week they get worse an’ worse!’

In a meek little voice, I replied, ‘That’s why I’m here—this one gets better and better.’”

Published on November 30th, 2018. Written by Laurence Marcus for Television Heaven.

Read Next...

Please Sir Film 1971

Mr Hedges puts his neck on the line when he pleads the case for his unruly class 5C to be allowed to go to summer camp for the first time. He's soon regretting his faith in his pupils as chaos reigns right from the start...

Also starring Noel Howlett

Noah's Ark tv series 1956

US drama series set in a veterinary hospital. Featuring television's first paraplegic character

Also tagged 1950S Drama

Judge Dee TV series

Ancient Chinese detective stories written in English by a modern Dutch diplomat.

Also tagged Drama Series

The Howerd Crowd

Frankie Howerd in a series of three shows written by Eric Sykes.

Also released in 1952

Mourning Becomes Electra BBC play 1952

Lauded by drama critics as a masterpiece of the modern stage, Mourning Becomes Electra with themes of murder, adultery, incestuous love and revenge, was the first substantial success of post-war television drama

Also released in 194719481952

Thora Hird as The First Lady

A female official takes her seat on a local council. But the no-nonsense councillor has to face up to the bureaucracy of both local and central government.

Also tagged Drama Series

Brond

Glasgow set thriller starring Stratford Johns as the amoral leader of the Scottish Liberation Army who is witnessed murdering a small boy on a bridge by a university student, who gradually gets drawn into a sequence of violent events...

Also starring Russell Hunter